bmap-tools

The better dd for embedded projects, based on block maps.

Introduction

bmaptool is a generic tool for creating the block map (bmap) for a file and copying files using the block map. The idea is that large files, like raw system image files, can be copied or flashed a lot faster and more reliably with bmaptool than with traditional tools, like dd or cp.

bmaptool was originally created for the "Tizen IVI" project and it was used for flashing system images to USB sticks and other block devices. bmaptool can also be used for general image flashing purposes, for example, flashing Fedora Linux OS distribution images to USB sticks.

Originally Tizen IVI images had been flashed using the dd tool, but bmaptool brought a number of advantages.

• Faster. Depending on various factors, like write speed, image size, how full is the image, and so on, bmaptool was 5-7 times faster than dd in the Tizen IVI project.
• Integrity. bmaptool verifies data integrity while flashing, which means that possible data corruptions will be noticed immediately.
• Usability. bmaptool can read images directly from the remote server, so users do not have to download images and save them locally.
• Protects user's data. Unlike dd, if you make a mistake and specify a wrong block device name, bmaptool will less likely destroy your data because it has protection mechanisms which, for example, prevent bmaptool from writing to a mounted block device.

Usage

bmaptool supports 2 subcommands:

• copy - copy a file to another file using bmap or flash an image to a block device
• create - create a bmap for a file

You can get usage reference for bmaptool and all the supported command using the -h or --help options:

$ bmaptool -h # General bmaptool help
$ bmaptool <cmd> -h # Help on the <cmd> sub-command

You can also refer to the bmaptool manual page:

$ man bmaptool

Concept

This section provides general information about the block map (bmap) necessary for understanding how bmaptool works. The structure of the section is:

• "Sparse files" - the bmap ideas are based on sparse files, so it is important to understand what sparse files are.
• "The block map" - explains what bmap is.
• "Raw images" - the main usage scenario for bmaptool is flashing raw images, which this section discusses.
• "Usage scenarios" - describes various possible bmap and bmaptool usage scenarios.

Sparse files

One of the main roles of a filesystem, generally speaking, is to map blocks of file data to disk sectors. Different file-systems do this mapping differently, and filesystem performance largely depends on how well the filesystem can do the mapping. The filesystem block size is usually 4KiB, but may also be 8KiB or larger.

Obviously, to implement the mapping, the file-system has to maintain some kind of on-disk index. For any file on the file-system, and any offset within the file, the index allows you to find the corresponding disk sector, which stores the file's data. Whenever we write to a file, the filesystem looks up the index and writes to the corresponding disk sectors. Sometimes the filesystem has to allocate new disk sectors and update the index (such as when appending data to the file). The filesystem index is sometimes referred to as the "filesystem metadata".

What happens if a file area is not mapped to any disk sectors? Is this possible? The answer is yes. It is possible and these unmapped areas are often called "holes". And those files which have holes are often called "sparse files".

All reasonable file-systems like Linux ext[234], btrfs, XFS, or Solaris XFS, and even Windows' NTFS, support sparse files. Old and less reasonable filesystems, like FAT, do not support holes.

Reading holes returns zeroes. Writing to a hole causes the filesystem to allocate disk sectors for the corresponding blocks. Here is how you can create a 4GiB file with all blocks unmapped, which means that the file consists of a huge 4GiB hole:

$ truncate -s 4G image.raw
$ stat image.raw
  File: image.raw
  Size: 4294967296   Blocks: 0     IO Block: 4096   regular file

Notice that image.raw is a 4GiB file, which occupies 0 blocks on the disk! So, the entire file's contents are not mapped anywhere. Reading this file would result in reading 4GiB of zeroes. If you write to the middle of the image.raw file, you'll end up with 2 holes and a mapped area in the middle.

Therefore:

• Sparse files are files with holes.
• Sparse files help save disk space, because, roughly speaking, holes do not occupy disk space.
• A hole is an unmapped area of a file, meaning that it is not mapped anywhere on the disk.
• Reading data from a hole returns zeroes.
• Writing data to a hole destroys it by forcing the filesystem to map corresponding file areas to disk sectors.
• Filesystems usually operate with blocks, so sizes and offsets of holes are aligned to the block boundary.

It is also useful to know that you should work with sparse files carefully. It is easy to accidentally expand a sparse file, that is, to map all holes to zero-filled disk areas. For example, scp always expands sparse files, the tar and rsync tools do the same, by default, unless you use the --sparse option. Compressing and then decompressing a sparse file usually expands it.

There are 2 ioctl's in Linux which allow you to find mapped and unmapped areas: FIBMAP and FIEMAP. The former is very old and is probably supported by all Linux systems, but it is rather limited and requires root privileges. The latter is a lot more advanced and does not require root privileges, but it is relatively new (added in Linux kernel, version 2.6.28).

Recent versions of the Linux kernel (starting from 3.1) also support the SEEK_HOLE and SEEK_DATA values for the whence argument of the standard lseek() system call. They allow positioning to the next hole and the next mapped area of the file.

Advanced Linux filesystems, in modern kernels, also allow "punching holes", meaning that it is possible to unmap any aligned area and turn it into a hole. This is implemented using the FALLOC_FL_PUNCH_HOLE mode of the fallocate() system call.

The bmap

The bmap is an XML file, which contains a list of mapped areas, plus some additional information about the file it was created for, for example:

• SHA256 checksum of the bmap file itself
• SHA256 checksum of the mapped areas
• the original file size
• amount of mapped data

The bmap file is designed to be both easily machine-readable and human-readable. All the machine-readable information is provided by XML tags. The human-oriented information is in XML comments, which explain the meaning of XML tags and provide useful information like amount of mapped data in percent and in MiB or GiB.

So, the best way to understand bmap is to just to read it. Here is an example of a bmap file.

Raw images

Raw images are the simplest type of system images which may be flashed to the target block device, block-by-block, without any further processing. Raw images just "mirror" the target block device: they usually start with the MBR sector. There is a partition table at the beginning of the image and one or more partitions containing filesystems, like ext4. Usually, no special tools are required to flash a raw image to the target block device. The standard dd command can do the job:

$ dd if=tizen-ivi-image.raw of=/dev/usb_stick

At first glance, raw images do not look very appealing because they are large and it takes a lot of time to flash them. However, with bmap, raw images become a much more attractive type of image. We will demonstrate this, using Tizen IVI as an example.

The Tizen IVI project uses raw images which take 3.7GiB in Tizen IVI 2.0 alpha. The images are created by the MIC tool. Here is a brief description of how MIC creates them:

• create a 3.7GiB sparse file, which will become the Tizen IVI image in the end
• partition the file using the parted tool
• format the partitions using the mkfs.ext4 tool
• loop-back mount all the partitions
• install all the required packages to the partitions: copy all the needed files and do all the tweaks
• unmount all loop-back-mounted image partitions, the image is ready
• generate the block map file for the image
• compress the image using bzip2, turning them into a small file, around 300MiB

The Tizen IVI raw images are initially sparse files. All the mapped blocks represent useful data and all the holes represent unused regions, which "contain" zeroes and do not have to be copied when flashing the image. Although information about holes is lost once the image gets compressed, the bmap file still has it and it can be used to reconstruct the uncompressed image or to flash the image quickly, by copying only the mapped regions.

Raw images compress extremely well because the holes are essentially zeroes, which compress perfectly. This is why 3.7GiB Tizen IVI raw images, which contain about 1.1GiB of mapped blocks, take only 300MiB in a compressed form. And the important point is that you need to decompress them only while flashing. The bmaptool does this "on-the-fly".

Therefore:

• raw images are distributed in a compressed form, and they are almost as small as a tarball (that includes all the data the image would take)
• the bmap file and the bmaptool make it possible to quickly flash the compressed raw image to the target block device
• optionally, the bmaptool can reconstruct the original uncompressed sparse raw image file

And, what is even more important, is that flashing raw images is extremely fast because you write directly to the block device, and write sequentially.

Another great thing about raw images is that they may be 100% ready-to-go and all you need to do is to put the image on your device "as-is". You do not have to know the image format, which partitions and filesystems it contains, etc. This is simple and robust.

Usage scenarios

Flashing or copying large images is the main bmaptool use case. The idea is that if you have a raw image file and its bmap, you can flash it to a device by writing only the mapped blocks and skipping the unmapped blocks.

What this basically means is that with bmap it is not necessary to try to minimize the raw image size by making the partitions small, which would require resizing them. The image can contain huge multi-gigabyte partitions, just like the target device requires. The image will then be a huge sparse file, with little mapped data. And because unmapped areas "contain" zeroes, the huge image will compress extremely well, so the huge image will be very small in compressed form. It can then be distributed in compressed form, and flashed very quickly with bmaptool and the bmap file, because bmaptool will decompress the image on-the-fly and write only mapped areas.

The additional benefit of using bmap for flashing is the checksum verification. Indeed, the bmaptool create command generates SHA256 checksums for all mapped block ranges, and the bmaptool copy command verifies the checksums while writing. Integrity of the bmap file itself is also protected by a SHA256 checksum and bmaptool verifies it before starting flashing.

On top of this, the bmap file can be signed using OpenPGP (gpg) and bmaptool automatically verifies the signature if it is present. This allows for verifying the bmap file integrity and authoring. And since the bmap file contains SHA256 checksums for all the mapped image data, the bmap file signature verification should be enough to guarantee integrity and authoring of the image file.

The second usage scenario is reconstructing sparse files Generally speaking, if you had a sparse file but then expanded it, there is no way to reconstruct it. In some cases, something like

$ cp --sparse=always expanded.file reconstructed.file

would be enough. However, a file reconstructed this way will not necessarily be the same as the original sparse file. The original sparse file could have contained mapped blocks filled with all zeroes (not holes), and, in the reconstructed file, these blocks will become holes. In some cases, this does not matter. For example, if you just want to save disk space. However, for raw images, flashing it does matter, because it is essential to write zero-filled blocks and not skip them. Indeed, if you do not write the zero-filled block to corresponding disk sectors which, presumably, contain garbage, you end up with garbage in those blocks. In other words, when we are talking about flashing raw images, the difference between zero-filled blocks and holes in the original image is essential because zero-filled blocks are the required blocks which are expected to contain zeroes, while holes are just unneeded blocks with no expectations regarding the contents.

bmaptool may be helpful for reconstructing sparse files properly. Before the sparse file is expanded, you should generate its bmap (for example, by using the bmaptool create command). Then you may compress your file or, otherwise, expand it. Later on, you may reconstruct it using the bmaptool copy command.

Project structure

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| - bmaptool                 | A tools to create bmap and copy with bmap. Based    |
|                            | on the 'BmapCreate.py' and 'BmapCopy.py' modules.   |
| - setup.py                 | A script to turn the entire bmap-tools project      |
|                            | into a python egg.                                  |
| - setup.cfg                | contains a piece of nose tests configuration        |
| - .coveragerc              | lists files to include into test coverage report    |
| - TODO                     | Just a list of things to be done for the project.   |
| - make_a_release.sh        | Most people may ignore this script. It is used by   |
|                            | maintainer when creating a new release.             |
| - tests/                   | Contains the project unit-tests.                    |
|   | - test_api_base.py     | Tests the base API modules: 'BmapCreate.py' and     |
|   |                        | 'BmapCopy.py'.                                      |
|   | - test_filemap.py      | Tests the 'Filemap.py' module.                      |
|   | - test_compat.py       | Tests that new BmapCopy implementations support old |
|   |                        | bmap formats, and old BmapCopy implementations      |
|   |                        | support new compatible bmap fomrats.                |
|   | - test_bmap_helpers.py | Tests the 'BmapHelpers.py' module.                  |
|   | - helpers.py           | Helper functions shared between the unit-tests.     |
|   | - test-data/           | Data files for the unit-tests                       |
|   | - oldcodebase/         | Copies of old BmapCopy implementations for bmap     |
|   |                        | format forward-compatibility verification.          |
| - bmaptools/               | The API modules which implement all the bmap        |
|   |                        | functionality.                                      |
|   | - BmapCreate.py        | Creates a bmap for a given file.                    |
|   | - BmapCopy.py          | Implements copying of an image using its bmap.      |
|   | - Filemap.py           | Allows for reading files' block map.                |
|   | - BmapHelpers.py       | Just helper functions used all over the project.    |
|   | - TransRead.py         | Provides a transparent way to read various kind of  |
|   |                        | files (compressed, etc)                             |
| - debian/*                 | Debian packaging for the project.                   |
| - doc/*                    | Project documentation.                              |
| - packaging/*              | RPM packaging (Fedora & OpenSuse) for the project.  |
| - contrib/*                | Various contributions that may be useful, but       |
|                            | project maintainers do not really test or maintain. |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

How to run unit tests

Just install the nose python test framework and run the nosetests command in the project root directory. If you want to see tests coverage report, run nosetests --with-coverage.

Known Issues

ZFS File System

If running on the ZFS file system, the Linux ZFS kernel driver parameters configuration can cause the finding of mapped and unmapped areas to fail. This can be fixed temporarily by doing the following:

$ echo 1 | sudo tee -a /sys/module/zfs/parameters/zfs_dmu_offset_next_sync

However, if a permanent solution is required then perform the following:

$ echo "options zfs zfs_dmu_offset_next_sync=1" | sudo tee -a /etc/modprobe.d/zfs.conf

Depending upon your Linux distro, you may also need to do the following to ensure that the permanent change is updated in all your initramfs images:

$ sudo update-initramfs -u -k all

To verify the temporary or permanent change has worked you can use the following which should return 1:

$ cat /sys/module/zfs/parameters/zfs_dmu_offset_next_sync

More details can be found in the OpenZFS documentation.

Project and maintainer

The bmap-tools project implements bmap-related tools and API modules. The entire project is written in python and supports python 2.7 and python 3.x.

The project author is Artem Bityutskiy ([email protected]). Artem is looking for a new maintainer for the project. Anyone actively contributing may become a maintainer. Please, let Artem know if you volunteer to be one.

Project git repository is here: https://github.com/intel/bmap-tools.git

Credits

• Ed Bartosh ([email protected]) for helping me with learning python (this is my first python project) and working with the Tizen IVI infrastructure. Ed also implemented the packaging.
• Alexander Kanevskiy ([email protected]) and Kevin Wang ([email protected]) for helping with integrating this stuff to the Tizen IVI infrastructure.
• Simon McVittie ([email protected]) for improving Debian packaging and fixing bmaptool.