SharpFuzz: AFL-based fuzz testing for .NET
SharpFuzz is a tool that brings the power of afl-fuzz to .NET platform. If you want to learn more about fuzzing, my motivation for writing SharpFuzz, the types of bugs it can find, or the technical details about how the integration with afl-fuzz works, read my blog post SharpFuzz: Bringing the power of afl-fuzz to .NET platform.
Table of contents
CVE
- CVE-2019-0980: .NET Framework and .NET Core Denial of Service Vulnerability
- CVE-2019-0981: .NET Framework and .NET Core Denial of Service Vulnerability
Articles
- SharpFuzz: Bringing the power of afl-fuzz to .NET platform
- Five years of fuzzing .NET with SharpFuzz
- Letβs do DHCP: fuzzing
- Fuzzing C# on Windows with SharpFuzz and libfuzzer-dotnet
Trophies
If you find some interesting bugs with SharpFuzz, and are comfortable with sharing them, I would love to add them to this list. Please send me an email, make a pull request for the README file, or file an issue.
- AngleSharp: HtmlParser.Parse throws InvalidOperationException fixed
- CoreFX: BigInteger.TryParse out-of-bounds access fixed
- CoreFX: BinaryFormatter.Deserialize throws many unexpected exceptions fixed
- CoreFX: DataContractJsonSerializer.ReadObject throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException
- CoreFX: DataContractJsonSerializer.ReadObject throws IndexOutOfRangeException
- CoreFX: DataContractSerializer.ReadObject throws ArgumentNullException
- CoreFX: Double.Parse throws AccessViolationException on .NET Core 3.0 fixed
- CoreFX: G17 format specifier doesn't always round-trip double values fixed
- CoreFX: Uri.TryCreate throws IndexOutOfRangeException
- CoreFX: XmlReader.Create throws IndexOutOfRangeException fixed
- DotLiquid: Template.Parse throws ArgumentNullException instead of SyntaxException
- Esprima .NET: JavaScriptParser.ParseProgram throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- Esprima .NET: StackOverflowException when parsing a lot of starting parentheses fixed
- ExcelDataReader: ExcelReaderFactory.CreateBinaryReader can throw unexpected exceptions fixed
- ExcelDataReader: ExcelReaderFactory.CreateBinaryReader throws OutOfMemoryException fixed
- ExCSS: StylesheetParser.Parse throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- Fluid: FluidTemplate.TryParse and FluidTemplateExtensions.Render throw some unexpected exceptions fixed
- Fluid: FluidTemplateExtensions.Render hangs permanently fixed
- Google.Protobuf: MessageParser.ParseFrom throws unexpected exceptions (C#) fixed
- GraphQL-Parser: Parser.Parse takes around 18s to parse the 58K file fixed
- GraphQL-Parser: Parser.Parse throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- Handlebars.Net: Handlebars.Compile hangs permanently fixed
- Handlebars.Net: Template engine throws some unexpected exceptions fixed
- Jil: JSON.DeserializeDynamic throws ArgumentException fixed
- Jint: Engine.Execute can throw many unexpected exceptions fixed
- Jint: Engine.Execute takes more than two minutes to complete (even with the 2s timeout) fixed
- Jint: Engine.Execute throws OutOfMemoryException after 45s (even with the 2s timeout) fixed
- Json.NET: JsonConvert.DeserializeObject can throw several unexpected exceptions
- Jurassic: ScriptEngine.Execute terminates the process with StackOverflowException
- Jurassic: ScriptEngine.Execute throws some unexpected exceptions fixed
- Jurassic: ScriptEngine.ExecuteFile hangs permanently instead of throwing JavaScriptException fixed
- Jurassic: ScriptEngine.ExecuteFile throws FormatException fixed
- LumenWorks CSV Reader: CsvReader.ReadNextRecord throws IndexOutOfRangeException
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml hangs permanently fixed
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml takes more than two minutes to complete when processing the 32K file fixed
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml throws IndexOutOfRangeException fixed
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml throws IndexOutOfRangeException fixed
- Markdig: Markdown.ToHtml throws NullReferenceException fixed
- Markdig: StackOverflowException is throw when converting special markdown to HTML fixed
- MarkdownSharp: Markdown.Transform hangs permanently
- MessagePack for C#: MessagePackSerializer.Deserialize hangs permanently fixed
- MessagePack for CLI: Unpacking.UnpackObject throws several unexpected exceptions
- Mono.Cecil: ModuleDefinition.ReadModule can throw many (possibly) unexpected exceptions
- Mono.Cecil: ModuleDefinition.ReadModule hangs permanently fixed
- NCrontab: CrontabSchedule.Parse throws OverflowException instead of CrontabException
- nHapi: Bad inputs cause unexpected exceptions and permanent hang fixed
- nHapi: Bad inputs cause StackOverflow/Access Violation fixed
- NUglify: Uglify.Js hangs permanently fixed
- Open XML SDK: Add some security/fuzz testing
- OpenMCDF: OutOfMemoryException when parsing Excel document / endless while-loop fixed
- OpenMCDF: System.ArgumentOutOfRangeException take 2 fixed
- OpenMCDF: System.ArgumentOutOfRangeException when trying to open certain invalid files fixed
- OpenMCDF: System.OutOfMemoryException when reading corrupt Word document fixed
- PdfPig: StackOverflowException reading corrupt PDF document fixed
- protobuf-net: Serializer.Deserialize can throw many unexpected exceptions
- protobuf-net: Serializer.Deserialize hangs permanently fixed
- Scriban: Template.ParseLiquid throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- Scriban: Template.ParseLiquid throws NullReferenceException fixed
- Scriban: Template.Render throws InvalidCastException fixed
- SharpCompress: Enumerating ZipArchive.Entries collection throws NullReferenceException
- SharpZipLib: ZipInputStream.GetNextEntry hangs permanently fixed
- SixLabors.Fonts: FontDescription.LoadDescription throws ArgumentException fixed
- SixLabors.Fonts: FontDescription.LoadDescription throws NullReferenceException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load terminates the process with AccessViolationException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws AccessViolationException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws ArgumentException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws ArgumentOutOfRangeException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws DivideByZeroException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws DivideByZeroException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws ExecutionEngineException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws IndexOutOfRangeException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws NullReferenceException fixed
- SixLabors.ImageSharp: Image.Load throws NullReferenceException fixed
- Utf8Json: JsonSerializer.Deserialize can throw many unexpected exceptions
- Web Markup Minifier: HtmlMinifier.Minify hangs permanently fixed
- Web Markup Minifier: HtmlMinifier.Minify throws InvalidOperationException fixed
- YamlDotNet: YamlStream.Load takes more than 60s to parse the 37K file
- YamlDotNet: YamlStream.Load terminates the process with StackOverflowException
- YamlDotNet: YamlStream.Load throws ArgumentException
Requirements
AFL works on Linux and macOS. If you are using Windows, you can use any Linux distribution that works under the Windows Subsystem for Linux. For native Windows support, you can use libFuzzer instead of AFL.
You will need GNU make and a working compiler (gcc or clang) in order to compile afl-fuzz. You will also need to have the .NET Core 2.1 or greater installed on your machine in order to instrument .NET assemblies with SharpFuzz.
To simplify your fuzzing experience, it's also recommended to install PowerShell.
Installation
You can install afl-fuzz and SharpFuzz.CommandLine global .NET tool by running the following script:
#/bin/sh
set -eux
# Download and extract the latest afl-fuzz source package
wget http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/afl/releases/afl-latest.tgz
tar -xvf afl-latest.tgz
rm afl-latest.tgz
cd afl-2.52b/
# Install afl-fuzz
sudo make install
cd ..
rm -rf afl-2.52b/
# Install SharpFuzz.CommandLine global .NET tool
dotnet tool install --global SharpFuzz.CommandLine
Usage
This tutorial assumes that you are somewhat familiar with afl-fuzz. If you don't know anything about it, you should first read the AFL quick start guide and the afl-fuzz README. If you have enough time, I would also recommend reading Understanding the status screen and Technical whitepaper for afl-fuzz.
As an example, we are going to fuzz Jil, which is a fast JSON serializer and deserializer (see SharpFuzz.Samples for many more examples of complete fuzzing projects).
1. Create a new .NET console project, then add Jil and SharpFuzz packages to it by running the following commands:
dotnet add package Jil
dotnet add package SharpFuzz
2. In your Main function, call SharpFuzz.Fuzzer.OutOfProcess.Run with the function that you want to test as a parameter:
using System;
using System.IO;
using SharpFuzz;
namespace Jil.Fuzz
{
public class Program
{
public static void Main(string[] args)
{
Fuzzer.OutOfProcess.Run(stream =>
{
try
{
using (var reader = new StreamReader(stream))
{
JSON.DeserializeDynamic(reader);
}
}
catch (DeserializationException) { }
});
}
}
}
We want to fuzz the deserialization capabilities of Jil, which is why we are calling the JSON.DeserializeDynamic method. The input data will be provided to us via the stream parameter (if the code you are testing takes its input as a string, you can use an additional overload of Fuzzer.OutOfProcess.Run that accepts Action<string>).
If the code passed to Fuzzer.OutOfProcess.Run throws an exception, it will be reported to afl-fuzz as a crash. However, we want to treat only unexpected exceptions as bugs. DeserializationException is what we expect when we encounter an invalid JSON input, which is why we catch it in our example.
3. Create a directory with some test cases (one test is usually more than enough). Test files should contain some input that is accepted by your code as valid, and should also be as small as possible. For example, this is the JSON I'm using for testing JSON deserializers:
{"menu":{"id":1,"val":"X","pop":{"a":[{"click":"Open()"},{"click":"Close()"}]}}}
4. Let's say that your project is called Fuzzing.csproj
and that your test cases are in the Testcases
directory.
Start fuzzing by running the fuzz.ps1 script like this:
pwsh scripts/fuzz.ps1 Jil.Fuzz.csproj -i Testcases
For formats such as HTML, JavaScript, JSON, or SQL,
the fuzzing process can be greatly improved with
the usage of a dictionary file. AFL comes with
bunch of dictionaries, which you can find after
installation in /usr/local/share/afl/dictionaries/
.
With this in mind, we can improve our fuzzing of Jil like this:
pwsh scripts/fuzz.ps1 Jil.Fuzz.csproj -i Testcases \
-x /usr/local/share/afl/dictionaries/json.dict
5. Sit back and relax! You will often have some useful results within minutes, but sometimes it can take more than a day, so be patient.
The input files responsible for unhandled exceptions will
appear in the findings/crashes
directory. The total
number of unique crashes will be displayed in red on the
afl-fuzz status screen.
In practice, the real number of unique exceptions will often be much lower than the reported number, which is why it's usually best to write a small program that just goes through the crashing inputs, runs the fuzzing function on each of them, and saves only the inputs that produce unique stack traces.
Advanced topics
- Fuzzing .NET Core
- Out-of-process fuzzing
- Test case minimization
- Using libFuzzer with SharpFuzz
- Legacy usage instructions
Acknowledgements
- Joe Ranweiler and the MORSE team - libFuzzer support on Windows
- Michal Zalewski - american fuzzy lop
- Dmitry Vyukov - go-fuzz: randomized testing for Go
- Rody Kersten - Kelinci: AFL-based fuzzing for Java
- Jb Evain - Mono.Cecil
- 0xd4d - dnlib
- Guido Vranken - go-fuzz: libFuzzer support